Faith It 'Til You Make It
Faith It 'Til You Make It
Welcome to Faith It 'Til You Make It—the podcast for people who love Jesus but also have a tendency to cry in parking lots. Hosted by Rachael (that’s me—hi), this show is for the spiritually curious, the burnt-out believers, and anyone who's ever tried to pray through gritted teeth. I started this podcast because life is messy, faith is complicated, and I got tired of pretending I had it all together. Spoiler: I don’t. Neither do you. That’s why we’re here. Each week, I show up—cracked heart, caffeine in hand—to talk honestly about what it means to walk with God when nothing feels very holy. There will be laughter. There will be oversharing. There may be emotional whiplash. So if you’re over curated perfection and want something real, raw, and occasionally ridiculous... pull up a chair. You’re in messy, blessed company.
Choose your favorite podcast player
Feb. 16, 2026

Feeling Fake: Christian Imposter Syndrome

Feeling Fake: Christian Imposter Syndrome

Have you ever felt like your growth looks fake?

Like you’re trying on a version of yourself that doesn’t quite fit yet — especially in your faith?

In this episode of Faith It ’Til You Make It, we’re unpacking what it really means to feel like an imposter after salvation. What if that awkward tension isn’t fraudulence… but formation? What if the discomfort isn’t hypocrisy… but growth?

We’ll talk about:

  • The difference between justification and sanctification

  • Why spiritual growth feels oversized before it feels natural

  • How grief can masquerade as imposter syndrome

  • What happens when people “miss your middle” and mistake transformation for performance

  • The temptation to shrink so you feel familiar again

If you’ve ever wondered whether you’ve changed too much — or not enough — this conversation is for you.

The middle isn’t proof you’re fake.
It’s proof you’re forming.

Stay faithful. Stay becoming. And faith it ’til you make it.

Send a Voicemail